The AI Overview Era: What Google’s Generative Search Means for SEO in 2025

what's an AI overview?Google’s AI Overviews have fundamentally changed how information surfaces online. What began as an experiment in 2024 is now a defining feature of the search landscape, appearing in up to one in five queries. For users, it means faster answers. For SEO professionals, it means a new reality: visibility doesn’t always equal clicks.

This is the next chapter of search — and the numbers tell a powerful story.

AI Overviews are spreading fast

According to several 2025 studies, AI Overviews have grown rapidly:

  • Semrush / Datos: Present in 13.14% of U.S. desktop searches (March 2025).

  • Conductor: Found in 16% of over 118 million analyzed keywords.

  • Pew Research: Around 18% of all searches now trigger an AI-generated summary.

For long-tail queries — especially those that start with “how,” “why,” or “what” — the percentage is even higher. This reflects Google’s clear direction: faster answers, fewer clicks.

Why informational queries dominate

Approximately 88% of all AI Overviews appear for informational intent queries. These are searches where users are seeking knowledge rather than products, transactions, or locations.

That aligns perfectly with Google’s mission: help users get information faster. Rather than replacing websites, AI Overviews act as high-level summaries that condense top results into a single, scannable view. For the user, it’s efficient. For SEOs, it’s a paradigm shift.

What the data shows about clicks and engagement

Research over the past six months paints a clear picture of changing engagement behavior:

  • CTR impact: The #1 organic result’s average click-through rate fell from ~28% to ~19% after AI Overviews rolled out.

  • Ahrefs: Found a 34.5% CTR decline for top-ranking pages when an AI Overview appears.

  • Amsive: Recorded a 15–20% average drop, with steepest declines when featured snippets and AI Overviews overlap.

  • Pew Research: Users click traditional results only 8% of the time when summaries are present, compared to 15% without them.

For many websites, these aren’t hypothetical numbers — they translate to significant shifts in visibility and conversions.

Does this mean organic SEO is dying?

No — but it does mean the playing field is changing. Traditional SEO tactics designed to win a blue link click are less reliable in an AI-driven environment. The focus now is earning inclusion within AI Overviews themselves.

The median scroll depth within AI Overviews is only 30%, meaning most users find their answers near the top. But being cited in the overview — even without a direct click — can strengthen brand authority, visibility, and perceived trust.

AI Overviews don’t eliminate the need for SEO; they reward better structured, authoritative, and contextually rich content that search engines can easily summarize.

Traffic shifts by industry

Traffic impacts vary depending on the niche:

  • News and informational publishers report declines of 20–50%, with some desktop queries seeing drops beyond 56%.

  • Commercial queries remain steadier, since Google’s generative summaries often avoid transactional intent for now.

In short: if your site thrives on informational content, it’s time to rethink your content strategy for the AI Overview layer.

How SEOs can adapt

To stay competitive, SEOs must evolve their frameworks. The new priorities include:

  • Semantic structure: Format content to help LLMs interpret context and relationships.

  • Authority and citations: Build credible, verifiable signals that make your content a trusted source.

  • Topic depth: Write for expertise, not just keywords — topical mastery is now a differentiator.

  • Monitoring new KPIs: Track impressions and citations within AI-generated results using emerging tools like Otterly.ai and Profound.

AI Overviews reward quality and clarity. The more your content answers questions directly — and in natural language — the more likely it will appear in Google’s generative results.

The bottom line

Google’s AI Overviews represent the biggest algorithmic and behavioral shift since mobile-first indexing. Roughly 20% of searches now generate AI summaries, CTRs are falling across key positions, and zero-click experiences are growing.

But this isn’t the end of SEO — it’s an evolution. Search professionals who align with Google’s generative intent rather than fighting against it will emerge ahead.

The dust hasn’t settled — but one thing is certain:
SEO in 2025 is no longer just about ranking. It’s about being understood.

Our agency specializes in elevating your online presence through cutting-edge SEO strategies. We’re not just consultants; we’re your partners in navigating the complex world of search engine optimization.
Copyright © 2025 Chicago SEO Consultant.